So I noticed a funny pattern after talking to other small business owners. Everyone starts with spreadsheets or something very bare-bones, and at some point they switch to real payroll software and never go back. I’m at that in-between stage now. Spreadsheets still technically work, but every payroll run is like a mini audit task. I'm leaning toward getting a software soon but don't know exactly what to look for. Is it about automation, tax handling, support, or just peace of mind? Genuinely curious. Please let me know.
Best payroll software for small business once you’re past spreadsheets?
byu/SamreetaZouwail inEntrepreneur
Posted by SamreetaZouwail
5 Comments
I started with Intuit payroll, but moved to Gusto and it was an improvement. I’d suggest that Gusto deserves consideration. W2 and 10199s are easy to manage and it includes a good hourly rate system with a timeclock feature that works pretty well too. Taxes and payments are also easy to manage.
Edit to add that it included a better PTO system and is flexible in how you an to set it up. I made it so that employees could manage their own PTO in the employee portal and submit requests which made that easier for me.
We use Xero, pretty sure it’s available globally. Lots of different tiers.
Yep, you’ve hit a classic scaling pain point. It’s less about a specific tool and more about buying back your time and headspace. The automation and tax handling is what gives you the peace of mind to focus on the business.
I just work with a company that handles it for me in the end it costs me less than most SaaS solutions out there and I have actual humans I can contact and who are taking care of the work
Xero does everything you need.