I'm trying to buy a place for myself as a single 27 year old guy who has lived with his parents his whole life.
In the area I want to buy, I essentially have two options: I can buy a polished, move-in ready and renovated condo on the 3rd (top) floor of a complex, cathedral ceilings, and a nice balcony. Or I can get a townhouse in need of work. The condo is 2br/2ba, townhouse is 2br/2.5ba. The monthly payment would roughly be the same (higher HOA fee/property taxes for the townhouse, but the asking price is a little cheaper than the condo).
The townhouse needs new flooring, bathrooms need some renovation, and new kitchen appliances. I love the look of the condo, and the cathedral ceilings look very nice, but I've always been told that a townhouse is more valuable than a condo. I don't know which one to go with.
Any advice/input would be appreciated.
A nice, polished 3rd floor condo, or a townhouse in need of work?
byu/MehDub11 inRealEstate
Posted by MehDub11
11 Comments
It’s true that townhouses have historically appreciated a bit better than condos, but it’s also location and detail specific.
As for which is “better”, it’s entirely personal preference. I’d rather have a move-in ready place than a fixer upper. Other people like the projects. What do you want?
I’ve lived in both and prefer the condo. More light and less work.
Townhouse would let you get some swear equity if you are handy and want that.
I’d buy a SFH if you can swing it. More upside.
One of my best friends is a multi-millionaire largely through her real estate investments. Her mantra, which I have followed, is buy the worst house in the best block you can afford. For me the townhouse would be my pick.
Can you do some of the improvements, would you want to? It is a personal decision there isn’t a right or wrong choice. I’m in the 8th house of my lifetime and probably my last. I have always enjoyed putting my mark on a place.
The house I am in now needed flooring on 2 levels, 3-bathroom guts, new windows, etc. etc. But it was cheap and even with the $80k I put into it; I am living in a place that rents for $2400-2600 a month for 1/2 of that monthly cost.
You haven’t yet learned about the reserves or the reserve study or read notes from past board meetings or any upcoming assessments. There’s a lot more to evaluate.
That includes rules on pets and noise and can you sublet and can you do short-term sublets? All these things impact value and use and resale value.
Also, the advice these days is don’t expect to sell and make money with in five years, but to expect to hold for 7 to 10 years because of instability nationally. (a beautiful condo can make you miserable if there’s no noise proofing between units and that has much to do with the way the building is constructed -that would be the same any place you were sharing a wall).
Is the townhome in an HOA and how old is each place?
The devil is in the details.
honestly man you’re kinda choosing between what feels good right now and what pays you back later. the condo is the easy win… you walk in, nothing stressing you out, no projects blowing up your weekends. that’s a big deal when it’s your first place and you’re tryna get your feet under you
the townhouse is the one that looks rough at first but lowkey ends up being the better move long term. every fix you do actually builds your equity instead of just being nice to have. and yea people say townhouses usually hold value better than condos, and that’s actually true in a lot of spots
it’s really just picking which version of yourself you wanna feed. the i want life simple and clean right now version… or the i’m cool grinding a bit so future me is sitting pretty version. neither is wrong. you just gotta feel which one fits where you’re at in real life, not on paper
As someone who lives in a 3 story TH get the condo
I’d really factor in the difference in the HOAs- in terms of monthly costs, how much they’ve historically gone up, and how they’re run as a major part of my decision
Even better, wait for a townhouse without an HOA
First time out, I recommend the renovated home. You’ll have enough on your plate just getting the hang of being on your own and dealing with issues that come up with homeownership. Take your time and get some experience and enjoy your new home. If you find you enjoy the repairs and renovations as time goes by, do a fixer on the next round. Congratulations!
Townhomes are generally better investments because the HOA fees stay more constant. Condo fees are higher and sometimes you will be hit with an assessment for a large capital improvement (roof needs replacing, balconies need repair, swimming pool needs resurfacing, etc). I like to be more in control of my costs so am wary of condos. If the building is less than 10 years old you are probably ok. Large capital improvements generally kick in 15+ years.