Autorecertification on but being told I’m overdue to recertify

I am on PAYE with Aidvantage and my account clearly says I have authorized autorecertification (and have been for years). On studentaid.gov my recert date is listed at 5/6/2026 but on Aidvantage it is listed as 4/1/2026. Not sure why there is a month discrepancy but I wasn't concerned because I filed my taxes in March. Now I've received a letter from Aidvantage saying I missed my recertification date and I have a 10 grace period before I get put on standard.

Should I just recertify manually? Even in the letter about missing my date it recommends approving autorecertification to avoid this problem but I am signed up for autorecert!