Neighbor hit my parked car (GA) – GEICO Diminished Value offer

Hey everyone, looking for some advice on a diminished value (DV) claim. I’m in Georgia, and my neighbor recently hit my parked car. She showed the police insurance info, but it turns out she didn't actually have coverage at the time.

Since she was uninsured, I had to go through my own insurance(GEICO). The damage was to the front bumper, side fender, and one of the tires. Total repairs came out to $3,200.

I’ve always kept my 2018 Elantra in great conditions and have never been in an accident before this. I was actually planning to sell the car right before this happened, and now I’m worried about how much value it’s lost.

The Offer:
• I asked GEICO for $2,000 in diminished value.

• They countered with $1,750

Is it worth appealing to get that extra $250? I know the real-world resale value probably dropped by way more than $1,750 now that it has an accident record. I could try to get a dealer quote or a professional appraisal to fight them, but since I'm only $250 away from what I asked for, I’m not sure if the stress is worth it.