I am soon to be the third family member to switch over to progressive from Geico. Recently my policy went up 30$ more a month for no reason.
Let me say my record and policy is absolutely spotless. Been with Geico for 16 years and they just don’t care. Never had one claim. 1 ticket. 1 anything.
They get me for 330$ a month for two 10 year old payed off average vehicles. I also have Defensive drivers applied.
So my brother basically has the exact same policy with his wife with Geico just went to Progressive and is paying 204$ a month from Geicos 350$.
Same Injury/Property/Liability numbers. So he will be saving nearly 900$ in 6 months.
My ex just switched over also. Going from like 230$ to 140$ monthly for her little civic.
What in the world is the catch here? Is Geico management asleep at the wheel or delusional? I’m located in New York which I’m sure affects the rates but lord have mercy.
I got quoted 200~ month also from 330$. That’s drastic. Something is up here.
What’s up with the recent massive surge of policy holders going to Progressive from Geico.
byu/Dry-Week1919 inInsurance
Posted by Dry-Week1919
1 Comment
Idk anyone that has recently moved from Progressive to GEICO. Insurance rates are cyclical. One company is never going to be the lowest forever. That is why you are told to shop around regularly. If you’ve been with the same company for 16 years, of course you would be shocked to know there are dozens of other companies that might be cheaper.
And, no, the insurance company doesn’t “care”. Insurance isn’t based on feelings or emotions. It’s based on statistics.