I’m very fond of the Stila Waterproof and would keep using it if I didn’t make my wallet bleed!!! I bought Nyx Epic Ink, which bled (in the physical sense) EVERYWHERE. Any suggestions for drugstore waterproof liquid eyeliner that works well for oily eyelids would be much appreciated. I used to wear a thick layer of eyeliner every day so it’s felt like a major disruption not to have a reliable brand around.

    Favorite liquid eyeliner under $15?
    byu/suzannetakesyoudown inFrugal



    Posted by suzannetakesyoudown

    2 Comments

    1. Outrageous-Tour-682 on

      wet n wild break up proof eyeliner!! they have a skinny version or a thicker one and both are great

    2. CrouchingGinger on

      2nd the WnW. Revlon ColorStay also works well and I think there’s one from Maybelline I’ve used. The only oily spots on my face are my lids and nose so I also need something that won’t bleed or transfer on hooded lids. Tried the L’Oréal cat eye one but I’d say the best consistency has come from WnW.

    Leave A Reply
    Share via
    Share via