Best credit card for annual expenses (utilities/biz expenses, etc)

Hello,

I was wondering what might be the best option for my annual/bi-annual expenses that include the following:

Propane

Auto Insurance

Homeowners Insurance

Cell Phone

SquareSpace Domains

Local MLS membership fees

CREDIT PROFILE

* Current credit cards you are the primary account holder of:

* Player 1:

* AMEX Blue Cash Preferred – $15,000

* Associated Bank / Elan – $9,000

* Apple Goldman Sachs – $7,500

* Citi Custom Cash – $8,600

* Player 2:

* Apple Goldman Sachs

* FICO scores with source: 725 – Transunion/Credit Karma / 709 – TransUnion/Credit Karma

* Oldest credit card account age: 14 years

* Cards approved in the past 6 months: 1

* Cards approved in the past 12 months: 1

* Cards approved in the past 24 months: 1

* Annual income $: $75K

CATEGORIES

* Ok with category-specific cards?: Yes

* Ok with rotating category cards?: No

* Estimate average monthly spend in the categories below.

* Dining $: n/a

* Groceries $: n/a

* Gas $: n/a

* Travel $: n/a

* Using abroad?: n/a

* Other categories or stores: n/a

* Other spend: n/a

* Pay rent by card? No

MEMBERSHIPS & SUBSCRIPTIONS

* Big bank customer: No

* Open to business cards: Maybe

PURPOSE

* Purpose of next card: Cashback

* Cards being considered: n/a

ADDITIONAL INFO

n/a

Thank you!