Hey all, looking for a sanity check here. Before anyone say this is AI, i used gpt to go over grammar and sentences.
For the 2025 tax year, it’s the first time my wife and I are filing jointly (doing taxes now), and I realized our combined income puts us over the Roth IRA limit.
I had already contributed the full amount to a Roth for 2025, so now I’m trying to fix it correctly.
From what I understand, the right approach is:
– Recharacterize the 2025 Roth contribution → Traditional IRA
– Then convert it back to Roth (backdoor)
Some details:
– By the time I recharacterize, the contribution will have some gains (roughly $1k)
– I already completed a backdoor Roth for 2026 earlier this year
– My Traditional IRA balance is currently $0 (everything has been converted)
My understanding so far:
– Recharacterization itself isn’t taxable
– When I convert, I only pay tax on the gains ($1k)
– I can convert the full amount (contribution + gains)
– Since my Traditional IRA is $0 at year-end, pro-rata shouldn’t apply
Questions:
-
Does this all sound correct?
-
Since both conversions (fixing 2025 + my 2026 backdoor) happen in 2026, do they just get combined on my 2026 taxes?
-
Anything I should watch out for (forms, timing, common mistakes)?
Just want to make sure I handle this cleanly and don’t create a bigger issue later. Appreciate any input.
Over income for Roth IRA (2025, first time MFJ) sanity check on backdoor fix
byu/fishfishfish1345 intax
Posted by fishfishfish1345