So I was poking around Carvana's filings this weekend and stumbled onto something I haven't really seen discussed.

    On April 30, Ernie Garcia II (founder, 10% holder) sold 4 million shares for $1.58B. Stock didn't really react. But the way he did it is what got my attention.

    A few things:

    – It's his first open-market sale in 24 months. He's been completely quiet.

    – He didn't use a 10b5-1 plan. That's how insiders usually pre-schedule sales so the market doesn't read them as a signal. He specifically opted out.

    – He wrapped the whole thing in covered calls and pledged the rest of his stock as collateral. Not a clean cash exit. More like a structured hedge with a big cash event attached.

    A founder who's been silent for two years and then drops a $1.58B sale with this kind of structure isn't doing routine selling. Either he needs that cash for something specific, or he doesn't trust the stock holding here, or it's just tax stuff (boring answer).

    Most coverage I saw just said "founder sold stock." But the structure is doing real work here. So I'm sitting here wondering why the price didn't move and whether I'm just reading it wrong.

    Anyone else been looking at this?

    (Disclosure: I've been building a tool that automatically reads SEC filings and flags this kind of thing. Not promoting per sub norms, happy to share if anyone DMs.)

    Am I the only one who noticed the Carvana founder just sold $1.58B with options wrapped around it?
    byu/spiderweb91 instocks



    Posted by spiderweb91

    2 Comments

    1. AMCorBUST2021 on

      Traded the markets for 25 years. I have never seen a company with such a strong insider sales signal. Not just Garcia. It’s the CFO, COO, President Special Product, VP of Accounting.. over the past year 223 Insider sells versus zero buys

      Valuation doesn’t matter. Finances don’t matter. Insider sells don’t matter. Just get Shaq for a commercial and boom pumpity-dumpity

    Leave A Reply