Go to https://galaxylamps.co/sabine, use the code SABINE, and get your Galaxy Projector with 15% off!
Phasing out nuclear power is the dumbest thing the Germans have ever done. Each time I say this on twitter, people come and tell me that Hitler did a few things that were even dumber. I disagree. Hitler wasn’t dumb, he was evil, he knew full well what he was doing. I’m not at all sure the current German government knows what it’s doing, and that isn’t a good thing either.
The German opposition to nuclear power is especially curious as our next door neighbours, the French and Dutch have no hesitation to use nuclear power to its full potential. Indeed, companies in both countries recently teamed up to bring small thorium reactors to Europe. Let’s have a look at what’s new.
🤓 Check out our new quiz app ➜ http://quizwithit.com/
💌 Support us on Donatebox ➜ https://donorbox.org/swtg
📝 Transcripts and written news on Substack ➜ https://sciencewtg.substack.com/
👉 Transcript with links to references on Patreon ➜ https://www.patreon.com/Sabine
📩 Free weekly science newsletter ➜ https://sabinehossenfelder.com/newsletter/
👂 Audio only podcast ➜ https://open.spotify.com/show/0MkNfXlKnMPEUMEeKQYmYC
🔗 Join this channel to get access to perks ➜
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC1yNl2E66ZzKApQdRuTQ4tw/join
🖼️ On instagram ➜ https://www.instagram.com/sciencewtg/
00:00 What’s New
04:28 Thorium Reactors
#science #technews #tech #sciencenews #nuclear
Phasing out nuclear power is the dumbest thing the Germans have ever done. Each time I say this on twitter, people come and tell me that Hitler did a few things that were even dumber. I disagree. Hitler wasn’t dumb, he was evil, he knew full well what he was doing. I’m not at all
Sure the current German government knows what it’s doing, and that isn’t a good thing either. The German opposition to nuclear power is especially curious as our next door neighbours, the French and Dutch have no hesitation to use nuclear power to its full potential. Indeed, companies in both countries recently teamed up to bring
Small thorium reactors to Europe. Let’s have a look at what’s new. The news is that two companies, Naarea of France and Thorizon of the Netherlands, have signed a partnership agreement to work on thorium fuelled small nuclear reactors. Thorizon, as the
Name indicates, specializes on using Thorium as nuclear fuel. Naarea is already working on small nuclear reactors, and they want to combine their technology with the Thorium cores from the Dutch. In case you’re wondering what their logo is supposed to show, that’s a radish. Yes,
A radish. Because, as they explain on the website: “The radish is a root vegetable that leaves no waste, as the entire plant is edible.” I looked it up and you know what it turns out that radish leaves are indeed edible, I had no idea. Ok, but back to nuclear power.
Small modular rectors have in recent years received a lot of attention. The idea is that rather than building one huge and expensive nuclear plant at location, you build smaller reactors that can then be transported to the place you want them. That
They’re modular means you can combine them to get a higher power output. Saying that they’re small is maybe somewhat of an overstatement. Not like you an put them into your pocket, but they’re just about small enough to be put onto a truck and be transported on the road.
Small modular reactors could solve two big problems with current nuclear power, which is that nuclear power plants are expensive and take a long time to build. Though if the small reactors really solve these problems, only time will tell. The two companies who have signed this agreement say they want to be catering
In particular to the industry where such a reactor wouldn’t be connected to the public electric grid. This makes a lot of sense because that way they can be put to use even faster. Suppose you have some energy intensive process in the manufacturing industry. Just take the factory
Off the grid, plug it onto a modular reactor, and the carbon footprint goes down dramatically, regardless of what the rest of the country does. You can also use the heat from the reactor directly, rather than making electricity from it first, which improves efficiently. The two companies each produce somewhat different reactors though,
Naarea is working on what they call an extra small nuclear reactor that will generate roughly 40 Megawatts of electricity, and they hope it’ll be done by 2030. Thorizon is working on a reactor with roughly 100 MegeWatts that is targeted at larger industrial customers. They want to have a pilot system ready before 2035.
If you like glowing blue and green lights but prefer them to be not radioactive, check out Galaxy Lamps who have made this video possible. The galaxy lamps projector makes every room special. It instantly transforms a room into
A colourful planetarium, with a truly unique look and feel. But not only that, it’s also a smart device. Let’s look at some of the features. First off, its RGB colours, brightness, rotation speed, on-off timers and many more are fully customizable. Grab your phone. With its app,
You can change everything — make it truly yours. Love using Amazon Alexa or Google Assistant? Well, the Galaxy Projector is on your team. Just say the word, and it obeys – from switching on to changing modes. Complete hands-free magic! And guess what? It’s energy-efficient too.
Enjoy your personal galaxy without worrying about your electricity bill skyrocketing. For those who appreciate good tech, this is for you. The Galaxy Projector is a modern gadget with what I’d call timeless appeal. Get your projector by clicking the link below
And use the discount code Sabine to get 15% OFF. But let’s talk a little more about those thorium reactors. Almost all currently operating nuclear reactors run on uranium. The only exception is one reactor in China which runs on thorium, though there are a few
Small test projects in the works. There are also some reactors, like the CANDU reactors, can run on either thorium or uranium though they all currently do run on uranium. Thorium has attracted attention in the past decades as an alternative nuclear
Fuel because in Earth’s crust it’s about 3 to 4 times more abundant than uranium. It also can’t be as readily used for nuclear weapons, though if you make some effort that’s still possible. The real advantage is of thorium reactors is however that they can use essentially
The entire thorium, not just a small fraction of it, as is the case with the normal uranium reactors. This, I assume, is why Naarea has the radish as a symbol, though maybe it means that their reactors will be red with green leaves on top, you never know.
That the thorium can be used almost entirely means that thorium reactors produce more energy from the same amount of fuel as uranium. As a consequence, thorium could last for thousands of years. Thorium is also a waste product of the rare-earth mining industry, so trying to put it
To use is a good idea. The downside is that since there is currently no dedicated thorium mining, it might go into short supply quickly, so there’s some commercial challenges ahead. The small nuclear thorium reactors work not with solid fuel rods, but with the fuel dissolved into
A liquid salt. This is why they’re called “molten salt reactors”. Modern molten salt reactors as all newer reactors come with passive safety features. This means that in the case of a loss of power oxygen masks will drop out from the panel above your head. Just checking if you’re listening. In
The case of a loss of power, the nuclear fuel will be automatically dumped into a place where it will cool rather than, in earlier reactors, go on to heat up and potentially cause the core to melt. That said, nuclear power is still dangerous, and I fully understand that many people
Are opposed to the technology because of the risk. However, everything has risks, and I think one also needs to take into account the risk of not using nuclear power because that means continuing to usi other sources of energy which also have risks. Nuclear power technology
Has changed a lot in the past 50 years and I really think Germany is missing the bus by not investing into it. So in case you’re from the German parliament, denkt nochmal drüber nach. Thanks for watching, see you tomorrow.
21 Comments
German: Die Deutsche Regierung weiß genau was sie tut!
Das Genehmigungsverfahren fur Atomreaktoren dauert ca. 20 Jahre in Deutschland. Eine Betriebsdauer von 10 – 15 Jahren ist nicht rentabel für Betreiber. Warum so kurz? Weil die regenerativen Energien in Deutschland so stark ausgebaut werden, das die teure Atomkraft nicht mehr gebraucht wird. Außerdem gibt es weltweit kein Atomendlager, außer in Russland. Dort kippt man den Atommüll ins Meer… Wesshalb die Woodkrabben auf eine Durchmesser von ca. 1m mutierten. Diese wandern gerade die Norwegische Küste herab Richtung Bergen… Abgesehen von dem enormen Risiko, siehe Japan, hatte Angela Merkel sehr weise entschieden aus sem Atomstrom auszusteigen. Dieser ist nur rentabel durch wahnsinnig hohe Subventionen beim Bau und bei der staatlichen Risikoübernahme. Wenn das alles, inkl. Endlager vollfinanziert werden müsste, wäte der Atomstrom unbezahlbar. In Schleswig-Holstein, wo ich lebe wurde in 2023 doppelt soviel regenerative Energie produziert, als benötigt…
Humans are not to be trusted with potentially dangerous materials.
History shows that quite clearly.
Nuclear power is a good and maybe planet saving idea, but sadly humans can’t be trusted.
The sad thing is, Europe doesn't invest in this at all. Should it work indeed, then China (and maybe USA) will be the market leaders, maybe even exclusive suppliers. So after solar, wind and battery power coming from China only, they are adding the next energy source to it. What a great idea. I'm still thinking, that free access to low cost energy is imperative for a prosperous economy.
"Hitler did some dumb things"
Sabine: "I disagree"
Uh… let her cook?
What we need is an absolutely massive nuclear fusion reactor. We could build it in space for safety, say 150million km away, and then transmit the energy back to earth as radiation, using the ionosphere to cut out any harmful rays. Then we could harvest that radiation to produce energy. What would be even better would be if that fusion reactor already existed and cost us nothing at all. Wow wouldnt that be good….
Molten Salt makes good sense and has excellent potential. 👍👍. It’s about time someone stepped up to commercialize this technology.
The former government in Germany was not so keen on Nuclear ether. I think it is a mistake. Even if I am not someone that think that nuclear is an easy problem to all energy needs. I do think that when built, you have done the hardest part. So decommissioning well functioning reactors is not the smartest idea.
This is an interesting video, though for me it completely missed the most important reason for opposition to nuclear power; that is, nuclear waste and the problems of long-term storage. A quick DuckDuckGo suggests that Thorium reactors have a significant advantage over traditional Uranium reactors, though they are not perfect. I'd like to see a more thorough analysis and discussion of this before I make up my mind.
I'm surprised the video missed this; I can't be the only person for whom the problem of centuries or millennia of radioactive waste is the biggest concern with nuclear power.
nice backdoor target? No thanks. With a bit of processing there is Plutonium to be extracted, bomb material. Ik brief: I think we should not bring radioactivity back after it had dissapeared making complex molecules stable and life possible.
Serious question: do SMRs not have to fulfill the regulations in regard of the Aircraft impact asessement of the NRC in the US or similar regulation in Europe? And if they do, are they really so easy to build and install?
👍
Here in Germany we do no longer think, when it comes to the strange german Energiewende. We just believe in the green religion and the political priests. And everyone who critisizes this stupid energypolicy is a heretic or defamed as a nazi. This is probably so, because the leading parties would have to admit, that they were wrong. And heroic politicians who promise to save the whole world from climateinferno do not really like to do so.
The United States is sitting on the largest thorium reserve in the world. 🌄
Radish greens make a really good pesto. Just use them in place of basil.
Hitler was Evil, a meth addict, arrogant, and kind of stupid. I agree just saying he was dumb which is why he did what he did is inaccurate, but all criminals think they are smarter than they really are and this lead him to make many strategic and tactical mistakes. IE attacking Russia in the winter with poorly equipped troops.
If it wasn't for the ignorant fear of nuclear power climate change wouldn't even be a topic of discussion and every cargo ship, and posisble even down to trains and tractor-trailer trucks would be nuclear powered and never need refueling after leaving the factory.
Nuclear powered submarines and aircraft carriers already use small nuclear reactors. So if you are looking out to sea in a remote part of Northern Germany there might be a nuclear reactor lurking under the water only a Kilometre away.
The Soviet Union had something like this to power their lighthouses but were abandoned during their political upheaval. A couple of hunters died recently using the core of one for a campfire.
Da kommen wir einfach nicht zusammen, ich als Biologin, Sie als Physikerin, da ist ein Riesen-Gap in Bezug auf die Gefahren der Kernkraft. Und nein, es sind nicht die Gefahren der Reaktoren, sondern einfach mal: Was machen wir mit dem Abfall? Was mich aber wirklich stört: Mit dem kurzen neuen Format ist die Werbungdichte erheblich angestiegen. Schade. Früher war es angenehmer, Ihnen zuzuhören, jetzt komme ich mir vor, als schaute ich Sat1 oder RTL. Schade, wirklich schade. Macht keinen Spaß mehr, sorry.
Solar Energy: Every second the sun radiates 1.4 Billion times more energy than the largest nuclear bomb, the 50 Megaton Tsara Bomba.
The Solar power output INCREASING for billions of more years (the sun will eventually evaporate the earth). And all we have to do is COLLECT IT.
China already has a small thorium molten salt reactor as a test bed to test all the processes and metallurgy needed for these reactors. ORNL was an advisor on this project which goes to show the ambivalence of the US in this sector. This reactor is running in the Gansu Desert since the end of 2022. Further, China is developing a thorium pebble bed reactor with the help of Germany and it is already operational.